Why yelp business is not working

why yelp business is not working

In recent years, many small and medium-sized businesses have found that their Yelp business profiles are not yielding the expected results. This article will explore the reasons behind this phenomenon while shedding light on potential changes.

The Role of Yelp in Local Search

Yelp was initially launched in 2004 as a search platform for customers interested in local services, restaurants, boutiques, and other businesses. Over the years, it has evolved into an online directory where users can find detailed information about establishments, read customer reviews, and even write their own evaluations.

With millions of visitors frequenting the site daily, it's no wonder that Yelp has become an essential digital marketing tool for businesses. But despite its relevance, many enterprises are struggling to see a tangible return on investment when using the platform.

Make your notice collection much easier on Yelp with Digifeel products

Yelp reviews card

Declining User Engagement

One major concern regarding Yelp's current state is the decline in user engagement. According to numerous studies, the number of active customers actively interacting with businesses through the site has been veritably dwindling.

Hoarding Older Reviews

One reason for the drop in engagement may be related to Yelp's practice of showcasing older reviews instead of putting more weight on recent evaluations in search results. While historical feedback may still provide valuable insight, customers are likely more interested in learning about present experiences - which could make older reviews seem less relevant over time.

Taking this approach, in turn, could discourage new users from leaving up-to-date evaluations and may result in fewer current recommendations available for those searching for fresh advice. 

Are you a professional? Find out our complete guide to boosting your Yelp reviews.

Effectiveness of Featured Listings

Paying to feature a listing on Yelp is one way brands hope to obtain better visibility and reach. However, the effectiveness of sponsored placements has come into question in recent years for multiple reasons.

Firstly, a growing number of businesses are opting to advertise on Yelp - which means that taking part in 'pay-to-play' may not guarantee the best possible presentation in search results. In addition, some customers have become wary of ads and may choose to ignore promoted listings entirely, therefore rendering them less effective.

Moderation Concerns

Yelp employs algorithms and human moderators to filter out fake reviews, strip business owners of any advantages accrued through their manipulation, and ensure an optimal user experience. However, there have been reports of inconsistency in moderation resulting in brands becoming plagued with undeserved negativity.

Lack of Transparency in Review Filters

Yelp's review filters remain undisclosed, making it difficult for small business owners to understand why certain evaluations get removed or retained. With the absence of visible guidelines, many entrepreneurs resort to trial-and-error methods as they navigate Yelp's parameters, ultimately wasting time and resources.

Moreover, legitimate positive feedback could be filtered out by overzealous protective measures hinder the potential benefits for businesses present on the platform.

Inconsistency Among Moderators

Another challenge faced by Yelp users is the alleged inconsistency among human moderators. Reports suggest that moderator decisions can vary significantly from one individual to another, creating confusion, frustration, and diminishing trust in Yelp's moderation process overall.

The Impact of Competing Platforms

Apart from internal aspects leading to Yelp's struggles, external factors also play a significant role – mainly being its rival offerings such as Google, Facebook, and other niche review platforms.

Google: An All-In-One Solution

Google's expansion into the review space through Google My Business is proving to be a fierce competitor for Yelp. With billions of users already using the platform for search queries, maps and directions, email, shopping, and more, adding business reviews compliments user experience seamlessly.

Furthermore, with Google My Business providing easier accessibility both on mobile devices and desktops, it presents a severe challenge to Yelp's position in the market.

Rising Power of Facebook Recommendations

Facebook recently introduced a 'Recommendations' feature that enables users to obtain opinions about products, services, and businesses from friends whom they trust. As the largest social network globally, Facebook is uniquely positioned to harness this power and seriously impact other review websites - Yelp included.

Niche Review Platforms

Yelp is also facing increased competition from niche review platforms, which deliver targeted information for specific industries such as travel (e.g., TripAdvisor), health (e.g., Healthgrades), and home services (e.g., Angie's List). Catering to a diverse range of customers, these specialized sites are increasingly taking a sizable chunk out of Yelp's relevance in certain niches.

  • Competition: As Yelp faces rising competition from all-in-one solutions like Google My Business and Facebook Recommendations, its ability to keep up diminishes.
  • Specialized Sites: The emergence of niche-specific review platforms focusing on one industry or marketplace takes away some of Yelp’s clientele who seek detailed insights tailored to their sector.

In light of several internal moderating, outdated practices, declining customer engagement, and external competition, it becomes clear why many businesses are not achieving desired outcomes on Yelp. To maintain its position it must adapt various functionalities while maintaining transparency and fostering customer trust for long-term success.

Back to blog